| Company | 100 gal | 150 gal | 200 gal | Last checked | Rating | Delivery | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bay Shore FuelSuffolk Lowest todayPosted price site says there is a 10 cent discount for cash, but its cash and card tables show the same prices | $4.799 | $4.749 | $4.699 | Oct 17, 10:53 AM ET | — | — | Order |
| Romeo's FuelSuffolk · Nassau Posted price $50 cancellation fee after order is placed | $5.349 | $5.299 | $5.229 | Oct 17, 10:53 AM ET | — | Posted delivery schedule | Order |
| Precision Heating OilSuffolk ZIP 11706 cash = posted price minus the 8¢ cash-on-delivery discount the site advertises | $5.450cashcard $5.530 | $5.400cashcard $5.480 | $5.350cashcard $5.430 | Oct 17, 10:53 AM ET | — | — | Order |
| Express COD (with Tragar)Suffolk · Nassau Posted price minimum order 100 gal; no cancellations; new customers: 5c/gal off first order (code NEW5) | $5.439 | $5.439 | $5.389 | Oct 17, 10:53 AM ET | — | Same day if ordered by 10 AM | Order |
| L&H Fuel OilSuffolk Posted price | $5.539cashcard $5.609 | $5.439cashcard $5.509 | $5.389cashcard $5.459 | Oct 17, 10:53 AM ET | — | — | Order |
| At Your Service OilNassau · Queens Posted price | $5.710 | $5.550 | $5.510 | Oct 17, 10:53 AM ET | — | — | Order |
| All Island ComfortSuffolk · Nassau ZIP 11550 | $5.599 | $5.559 | $5.459 | Oct 17, 10:53 AM ET | — | — | Order |
| Discount FuelSuffolk · Nassau · Queens ZIP 11550 | $5.599 | $5.559 | $5.459 | Oct 17, 10:53 AM ET | — | 24-hr / emergency | Order |
| Domino Fuel Inc.Suffolk · Nassau · Queens ZIP 11550 | $5.599 | $5.559 | $5.459 | Oct 17, 10:53 AM ET | ★ 4.7 | Same day · 24/7 | Order |
| Oilex HeatingNassau Posted price $50 cancellation fee; per-gallon from the page's order subtotal (earliest delivery date) | $5.650 | $5.590 | $5.530 | Oct 17, 10:53 AM ET | ★ 4.8 | Same day available | Order |
| Bonilla's Fuel ServicesSuffolk Posted price | $5.659cashcard $5.709 | $5.609cashcard $5.659 | $5.559cashcard $5.609 | Oct 17, 10:53 AM ET | — | — | Order |
| Anchor Fuel OilSuffolk · Nassau Posted price | $5.799 | $5.729 | $5.699 | Oct 17, 10:53 AM ET | — | — | Order |
| Bel-Mar OilNassau · Queens Posted price same price list for every city in its list; calculator adds city-specific tax | $5.850 | $5.790 | $5.750 | Oct 17, 10:53 AM ET | — | — | Order |
| Admiral EnergyQueens ZIP 11418 cash = posted price minus the 10¢ cash-on-delivery discount the site advertises | $5.940cashcard $6.040 | $5.840cashcard $5.940 | $5.840cashcard $5.940 | Oct 17, 10:53 AM ET | — | — | Order |
| Tandy OilSuffolk Posted price taxes not included (Suffolk 2.5%); East End delivery | $6.190 | $6.090 | $6.090 | Oct 17, 10:53 AM ET | — | COD or automatic | Order |
| Lakewood FuelQueens Posted price | $6.149 | $6.149 | $6.149 | Oct 17, 10:53 AM ET | — | Same / next day | Order |
| Paragon OilNassau · Queens ZIP 11361 earliest delivery October 20th, 2026 | $6.299 | $6.249 | $6.249 | Oct 17, 10:53 AM ET | — | — | Order |
| Aladdin Oil / Aladdin FuelSuffolk ZIP quote on dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | — | Full service or COD | Order |
| All Island FuelSuffolk · Nassau Check dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | — | — | Order |
| Bay Fuel Oil (Hart Home Comfort)Suffolk ZIP quote on dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | — | Automatic or COD | Order |
| JMB Fuel OilSuffolk · Nassau ZIP quote on dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | — | — | Order |
| John Taylor Heating Oil (Hendrickson Fuels)Suffolk ZIP quote on dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | ★ 5.0 | — | Order |
| John's Fuel OilSuffolk ZIP quote on dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | — | — | Order |
| OV Oil IncNassau · Queens ZIP quote on dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | — | — | Order |
| Power Fuel OilSuffolk ZIP quote on dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | — | 1–2 business days | Order |
| Sage OilNassau ZIP quote on dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | — | — | Order |
| Sunrise FuelSuffolk · Nassau ZIP quote on dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | — | — | Order |
| Wise Choice Fuel OilSuffolk · Nassau ZIP quote on dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | — | — | Order |
| D&G Fuel OilSuffolk · Nassau · Queens Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | — | — | — | Call |
| Devoe Fuel OilSuffolk Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | — | — | — | Call |
| Family Fuel & Heating ServiceSuffolk · Nassau · Queens Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | — | — | — | Order |
| JC Discount FuelSuffolk Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | — | — | — | Call |
| OK PetroleumSuffolk · Nassau Call or visit dealer site | Call or visit site | Call or visit site | Call or visit site | — | — | — | Visit site |
| Petro Home ServicesSuffolk · Nassau Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | — | — | Automatic delivery | Call |
| Suffolk OilSuffolk Call or visit dealer site | Call or visit site | Call or visit site | Call or visit site | — | — | — | Visit site |
| Sunset Fuel (All Island Fuel of Mastic)Suffolk Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | — | — | — | Call |
| Tragar Home ServicesSuffolk · Nassau Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | — | — | Automatic delivery | Call |
| Triboro EnergyNassau · Queens Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | — | — | — | Call |
Prices are read automatically from each dealer's own website (for ZIP-priced dealers, from sample ZIPs in each county; only a ZIP code is ever entered).
Per gallon, before sales tax unless noted. cash = cash/COD price; card price shown under it when different. Prices older than 36 hours are marked stale.
Readings that fail our sanity checks (outside $2–$9/gal, or a jump of more than 15%) are held for review and not shown. Ratings and delivery notes come from our earlier research and may be out of date. Always confirm price and fees with the dealer.